Quote-Driven Market vs Order-Driven Market: What is the Difference?
Understand how quote-driven and order-driven markets work, how prices are determined, and how liquidity, transparency and trade execution differ.
Quote-driven markets rely on dealers to set prices and provide liquidity from their inventory, while order-driven markets use a centralised order book where buyers and sellers submit their desired prices. The two structures differ in price discovery, liquidity, transparency and trade execution, making each suitable for different trading objectives.
For a market to work efficiently, it needs sellers and buyers. A system that lets buyers buy and sellers sell goods at a fair price ensures the market functions effectively.
Understanding how the market is structured provides insight into how you can trade your assets, like a stock or a commodity. Market structure generally falls into two types: a quote-driven market and an order-driven market.
Understanding how these market structures function and their implications can help you navigate the broking and trading landscape much more effectively.
In this article, we will understand what market structures are, their types and the key differences between them.
What is a Market Structure?
Market structure refers to how the market is organised based on the number of buyers and sellers, the ease of entry and exit, and the assets being traded. The structure of a market can suggest how competitive the market is and whether it is a single player or several participants who dominate it.
From a trading point of view, understanding the structure is important because, as a trader, you also want to be certain how easily you can buy and sell, and understand the pricing system.
What is a Quote-Driven Market?
In a quote-driven market, both the purchase and the selling prices are set by the dealer. The dealer, also known as the market maker, acts as an intermediary who connects the buyer and the seller and fulfils orders from their own inventory.
For example, a dealer quotes an ask price of a stock at $50.50 and a bid price for $50. This means you can either buy this stock for $50.50 or sell it for $50. If you meet these criteria, then you can execute the order immediately.
However, if someone bids $51 to purchase the same stock, then their order will be preferred. Similarly, if someone quotes to sell a stock at $49.50, then the market would consider them the new seller.
READ MORE: Commodity Trading Strategies in India
What is an Order-Driven Market?
In an order-driven market, the buyers and the sellers submit the quotes at which they want to trade. The order is submitted to a centralised order book where buyers and sellers can view stock prices and share quantities and place bids accordingly.
To understand the order-driven market better, here is an example:
No Trade Happens
The table depicts the conditions under which no trade will take place:
| Investor | Role | Time | Quantity | Price | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Investor A | Buyer | 09:30 a.m. | 100 shares | ₹150 | Pending |
| Investor B | Buyer | 09:31 a.m. | 200 shares | ₹150 | Pending |
| Investor C | Seller | NA | 100 shares | ₹151 | Pending |
Under these conditions, no trade can take place since neither Investor A nor Investor B are offering the price at which C wants to sell.
Conditions to Trigger a Trade
The table shows the conditions that must be fulfilled for the trade to get executed:
| Scenario | Actions Taken | Outcome | Result of the Order Book |
|---|---|---|---|
| Match Seller C | You buy 100 shares at ₹151 | The trade gets executed immediately, and the shares are allocated to you | Seller C’s order is fulfilled and subsequently removed from the system |
| Join the Queue for Buying | You bid for 100 shares at ₹150 at 09:35 a.m. | Order added to the waiting list | If Seller A makes the same bid as you, the shares get allocated to them since they offered to buy first |
This type of market is commonly seen on commodity exchanges like Multi-Commodity Exchange (MCX), London Metal Exchange (LME), and Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME).
Why does no trade take place when Investor A and Investor B bid ₹150 while Investor C wants to sell at ₹151?
Differences Between Quote-Driven Market and Order-Driven Market
The table below outlines the key differences between the quote-driven market and the order-driven market:
| Category | Quote-Driven Market | Order-Driven Market |
|---|---|---|
| Price Discovery | The system is decentralised. The trade occurs directly between the dealer and bidder. | The system is centralised, where an order book sets the price at which an asset will be traded. |
| Liquidity | Higher liquidity since the dealer commits their inventory to fulfil the bid. Ideal for assets with a large lot. | Liquidity can vary since it depends on the participation of both the buyer and the seller. |
| Transparency | Lower since traders are unable to view quotes, creating a market information advantage for the dealers. | High transparency as traders can view the selling and buying prices along with the volume traded. |
| Ease of Trade Execution | The execution is faster since the dealer fulfils the bid from their own inventory. | The trade is auction-based, where a trade is executed only when it matches the order price. |
Conclusion
Which market structure works best for you depends on your trading objective. If you seek higher liquidity and faster execution, then a quote-driven market is your best option; otherwise, you can opt for an order-driven market if you prefer a transparent pricing system allowing you to match the order smoothly and directly.
However, you must conduct proper due diligence so that you can navigate the markets to mitigate the risks and yield maximum profits.
All topics
Click the link, confirm the box next to sahi.com is checked — ignore any other results.